Hayde logo
← Back to blog

What a Free Coffee Really Costs You

By Royi Kenan · Published
What a Free Coffee Really Costs You

What a Free Coffee Really Costs You

Every owner who sets up a loyalty card has the same worry. "If I give away a free coffee, am I just throwing money away?"

It is a fair question. You worked hard for your margins, and the idea of handing a drink over for nothing feels wrong. So a lot of owners make the reward so hard to reach that nobody ever gets there, fifteen stamps for a small coffee, or skip the reward altogether and wonder why nobody bothers with the card.

Both mistakes come from the same misunderstanding. A free coffee does not cost what you think it costs.

The free coffee costs about one euro, not four

When a customer pays four euros for a coffee, that is the price, not the cost. The beans, the milk, the cup, the lid, the sugar: for most cafes that adds up to somewhere around one euro. Sometimes less.

So when someone redeems their tenth coffee free, you are not losing four euros. You are giving away about one euro of ingredients. The cup would have been poured anyway. The machine was already on.

Do the math on the whole card and it gets even clearer. Nine paid coffees at four euros is 36 euros of revenue. The free tenth coffee costs you about one euro in ingredients. That is less than 3 percent of the revenue those ten visits brought in.

A 3 percent cost to keep a customer coming back ten times. There is no ad on earth that cheap.

What the free coffee actually buys

Here is the part owners forget. The free coffee is not the point. The nine paid coffees before it are the point.

A loyalty card does not create a free coffee problem. It creates a reason for a customer to choose your place on Tuesday when they were going to try the new place down the street.

Ask yourself what one lost regular is worth. If a customer who used to come twice a week stops coming, that is eight visits a month gone. At four euros a visit, that is 32 euros a month, every month, from one person. The free coffee you were worried about costs one euro, once.

The expensive thing is not the reward. The expensive thing is the customer who quietly drifts away and never tells you why.

Where owners get the reward wrong

There are three common mistakes, and all three are easy to fix.

First, making the reward too hard to reach. Fifteen stamps for a coffee sounds safe, but nobody counts to fifteen. After five or six stamps with no reward in sight, people stop caring. Ten stamps is the sweet spot for most cafes: close enough to feel reachable, long enough to be worth your while.

Second, picking a reward that costs you real money. A free coffee is cheap for you and feels generous to the customer. A free lunch is not. It costs you ingredients, kitchen time, and a table. Pick a reward with high perceived value and low real cost: a coffee, a slice, a pastry, a small side.

Third, setting the reward once and never looking at it again. Your prices change, your costs change, your menu changes. The reward should change with them. Check it every few months. If your coffee now costs you 1.50 to make instead of 1 euro, the math still works. If it ever stops working, adjust the stamp count by one or two, not by rebuilding the whole card.

The simple rule for setting your reward

Here is a rule you can use for any reward on any menu. The reward should cost you less than 10 percent of what the customer spends to earn it.

For a coffee shop, that is easy: ten coffees at four euros is 40 euros of spend, and a one euro reward is 2.5 percent. You have room to be generous. For a restaurant, a free main after ten visits might cost you six or seven euros against 150 euros of spend, still under 5 percent. It works.

If your reward costs more than 10 percent of the spend to earn it, either raise the stamp count or pick a cheaper reward. If it costs less than 3 percent, you can probably afford to be a little more generous, and generosity is what makes people tell their friends about your card.

One more thing: a reward the customer can see coming is worth more than a bigger reward they cannot. A free coffee after ten visits beats a free brunch after thirty, every time. People finish what they can see the end of.

Try this week

Take your bestseller, the thing people already order most, and cost it out properly. Beans, milk, cup, lid, everything. Then work out what a buy nine get one free card really costs you as a percentage of the revenue those ten visits bring in.

If it is under 5 percent, your reward is too cheap to worry about, and you should be offering the card to every single customer. If it is over 10 percent, change the reward, not the idea. Pick the next item down the menu, or add one more stamp.

loyaltycafe owners